Skip to main content

Deconstructing Why I Don't Think SMART Goals Are All That Smart

If you've been in the work world long enough, I'm sure you've come across SMART goals at one point or another. SMART is a conveniently created acronym to help a person build essentially "reasonable" goals. These criterion are defined as the following:

  • Specific (simple, sensible significant)
  • Measurable (meaningful, motivating)
  • Achievable (agreed, attainable)
  • Relevant (reasonable, realistic and resourced, results-based)
  • Time-bound (time-based, time-limited, time-sensitive)

At first blush, I think most anybody can agree that these are good things to hold to. I've seen them practiced in organizational performance development, and I know they were deeply espoused in my Master's degree.

But I'm not sold on these criterion. When trying to recently use this formula for myself, I found myself frustrated by the limitations imposed by this method. Just like the title of this post says, I don't think SMART goals are all that smart. Let's deconstruct each of these criterion and examine why.

SPECIFIC

My problem with being specific is that a person tends to sweat the details to reach that goal. This isn't a bad thing in a setting like losing weight, but this can be severely detrimental in a business setting. I have sat in meetings for well-intentioned efforts immediately delve down into the ultimately valueless details because they served as a means to get to that end goal. When we focus on a bigger picture instead of something specific, the details tend to work themselves out. To that end, getting specific with your goals is a bad idea.

MEASURABLE

I honestly don't know why this is important. Because you want to pat yourself on the back in the end...? I think it makes the assumption that we can replicate our practices for similar goals in the future, and I just don't think that's all that true. Plus, specific goals rarely look the same, so I think it's just a waste of time keeping track of what worked and what didn't. We all remember the big things that really went well. Again, when we start sweating the little details, we lose sight of a grander prize.

ACHIEVABLE

I have the biggest problem with this criterion from both an optimistic and pessimistic perspective. From a pessimistic perspective, how do you know you can actually achieve your goal? We're operating under the assumption that your current goal is something that is not a present reality, so how can you certainly say something is or isn't achievable? From a perspective of optimism, how do you know this is the only thing you can achieve? How do you know you can't do more? When I was first losing weight, I set a goal of 50 pounds. After I hit that mark, I opened the goal up to a general "we'll see how far I can go". Turns out I was capable of losing 100 pounds. How do you know your "achievable" goal isn't limiting yourself?

RELEVANT

Of all these criterion, this is probably the only one I can get on board with. But come on, folks: this should be common sense! You don't seek to lose weight by working toward becoming an accountant. They just don't match up. We don't need the R in SMART to tell us that.

TIME-BOUND

Much like my thoughts on "Achievable", you don't truly ever know how long things take. Actually, I can make a pretty solid argument that most short term goals can be achieved much more quickly than what you might think. This is where "time-bound" really becomes a problem. Let's say you set out to earn you PMP within one year. As somebody who has their PMP, I can tell you that while it's tough, it can reasonably be done in about 3-4 months. So if you say in January that you'll get it within the year, guess when you're most likely to actually get it. Yup, December. And it's not because it takes a full year but rather because you allowed yourself the time to dilly dally.


Do you agree with these sentiments, or am I totally off base? Personally, I don't ever see me creating any SMART goals for myself in the future. I don't want to be constrained by a formula that places limitations on me. Instead, I want to see just how far I can push myself because, more often than not, I am surprised by the results. I think you might be surprised at what you're capable of, too, so I would encourage you all to always shoot higher than what you think is reasonable.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review: "The Dip" by Seth Godin

If you think you've seen this book before, you're probably not mistaken. It's not a new book at all. It came out in 2007, and the first time I read this book was actually back in 2011. For personal reasons, I chose to pick it back up, and I'll talk about that in a separate post. Having been five years since my last read, I'm glad I dug this back up. It's a pretty teeny book, as you can see in the image below. A person can definitely breeze through the entire book in an hour or two. Anyway, this is a book review! How does this book hold up in the nine years since it's initial release? Let's get into it.
Post a Comment
Read more

The Christian Civil War of 2016

There's no doubt that the outcome of the recent election had arguably the most divisive outcome in American history. People have not been afraid to voice their anger and concerns about Trump's election on social media. From what I've seen, the most vocalization has come from the left, and I honestly haven't seen a lot of overt support from the right. (That's another topic altogether.) What has quietly gone unaddressed is another issue that has stemmed from the election: a Christian civil war. As somebody who cares for the church, this something I definitely think needs addressed sooner rather than later.
Post a Comment
Read more

Be Mindful of Invisible Scripts

Whether we like it or not, assumptions pretty much drive our lives. We learn to live not because we have analyzed a certain matter thoroughly. Rather, much of what we know today was ingrained in us in our adolescent development. Some of these are more obvious. Take going to college, for example. When I graduated from high school, something like 90% of my graduating class planned on pursuing some sort of college education. Even if my parents didn't encourage me to go to college (they did), it still seemed like the thing I needed to do. But some things aren't so obvious. There are subtle things people do and say that guide our choices in a way we are oblivious to.
Post a Comment
Read more

Being Transparent about LYEATT's Analytics

I'm going to break off from my usual explanation of whatever trending idea to be open with you all about some stuff. I chose Blogger as the platform for this blog because it's housed under Google, and I find Google to be a trustworthy company. What I did not realize is the extent to which Blogger provides analytics. Obviously, I can't see exactly who is reading this blog, but I can see a number of other things. I can see where traffic is coming from, whether from LinkedIn or Twitter. I can also see how many times people have viewed each post. And I can also tell you that I wrote my first zero-view post recently. Also, to date, there has never been a single comment on any post. I'm not going to share which post that is because viewership is not the purpose of this blog, nor am I looking for anybody to comment now. But I will say that it is a little disheartening. This would normally have been the point where I'd shut down the blog and labeled it a failure. Bu...
Post a Comment
Read more

You're Out of Excuses

The Amazon Kindle Fire tablet is $50 and often goes on sale for cheaper than that. You can get free wifi almost anywhere, including most McDonald's locations. The best email platforms, Gmail and Yahoo, are free . Almost all social media platforms, including Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn, are free . My blog is hosted on the Blogger platform, which is free to use. If you have a library card, you can probably checkout digital ebooks for free via Overdrive. Apps like WhatsApp allow you to make calls to people for free . Interacting with people on social forums like Reddit is free . The barriers to entry have been lowered significantly. You don't have an excuse why you're not making yourself better anymore.
Post a Comment
Read more